Zmyslone fantazje

09.04.11, 18:28
Pamietacie swietej pamieci Jerzego Kosinskiego, autora Malowanych Ptakow. Lata temu Jurek dal wywiad o tek siazce do amerykanskich mediow, powiedzial ze wszystko w tej ksiazce jest doslowna prawda, w Radio Wolna Europa wyjasnil ze jest to abstrakcja literacka i nie ma nic wspolnego z historia. Jurek byl wielkim przyjacielem polskich atletow, ktorych przyjmowal w New York Athletic Club. Przyjaznil sie wiecej z Polakami niz z Zydami, lub Amerykanami.

This week Dr Piotr Setkiewicz, the head historian at Auschwitz, said that he did not believe Mr Avey’s story of the swap. He said that his fear was the story could provide ammunition for Holocaust deniers who are keen to exploit implausible memoirs in order to ‘prove’ that the Holocaust did not take place.

Webmaster's Commentary:
The problem is that all these memoirs turn out to be fakes. Oprah got duped by one! eBay is loaded with phony armbands sold as "souvenirs" of the alleged death camps. Misha Defonseca's story of being trapped in the Warsaw ghetto, then befriended by wolves after she escaped, was also a fake. Binjamin Wilkomirski’s Fragments was revealed as a hoax. The father of Anne Frank was sued by a writer for his work on The Diary of Anne Frank, and forced to pay $50,000. The Hitler Diaries were faked. The Painted Bird, by Polish emigre Jerzy Kosinsky, was a self-indulgent sex-torture fantasy set in WW2 Poland pretending to be history. Elie Wiesel continued to defend Kosinsky's work even after it was revealed as a hoax. Elie Weisel himself has been accused of being a fraud and imposter as well, as his Against Silence: The Voice & Vision of Elie Wiesel, Vol 2 (1985) described "geysers of blood", which could not actually have happened as described. The original book of "Schindler's List" although based on a real-life person, is a work of fiction, much of it highly inaccurate.

All of these hoaxes succeeded wildly because they pandered to the need for Jews to sell a certain vision of history in the controlled media. All the above hoaxes were celebrated, made required reading on colleges and high schools, heaped high with prestigious awards, even made into movies. Nobody dared question the rather ludicrous claims being made in the pages out of fear of being labeled an anti-Semite (as those who exposed the hoaxes inevitably were). Following the exposure, the blame is always put onto the Gentiles (Wilkomirski was not Jewish) or the claim is made that although the work isn't entirely true, it "captures the spirit" of the time, and is thus kept on the required reading lists.

But the lesson here is the bias. You can write the most carefully researched and referenced scientifically verifiable history of WW2 and be lambasted for it, even thrown in jail. But at the same time, any charlatan can pen a total fantasy about those evil Nazis, claim it is true without any proof, and be guaranteed heaps of cash and fame.


    • you-know-who Re: Zmyslone fantazje 09.04.11, 18:48
      owszem troche nazmyslali, wiekszosc niestety nie i na pewno nie chcialbys zeby to co zobiono im zrobiono tobie, mr p.

      autor "pianisty" tez jest troche niedokladny,
      wiki pisze, niezgodnie z prawda

      Dopiero w 1950 Szpilmanowi udało się poznać tożsamość tego Niemca, lecz nie udało mu się już uwolnić go z niewoli sowieckiej (era "zimnej wojny" po 1948). Hosenfeld zmarł później w obozie jenieckim w 1952.

      nie udalo mu sie, bo nie probowal. po dostaniu listu z sojuza od niemca, nie zrobil nic by mu pomoc. nie wiem nawet czy to jest znany publicznie fakt.

      koretka do twojego pisarstwa:
      "zmyslone fantazje"? to maslo maslane.
      "autora Malowanych Ptakow"? ile ich tam bylo? po ang. tylko jeden.
    • mlody747 Ciekaw co jest zmyslona fantazja? Oficjalna wesja? 09.04.11, 21:52
      Czytaj ta gazetę, jak pisano przed IIWS i porównaj z dzisiaj oficjalna wersja wydążeń z tamtych lat. Mozę należało by się zapytać: kto podaje teorie spiskowe za prawdziwe, a obmawia prawdziwe wydarzenia, jako "teoria spiskowa".
      whatreallyhappened.com/IMAGES/judea_declares_war_on_germany.jpg
      • misterpee Re: Fantazje Obamy na bierzaco 10.04.11, 02:37
        www.youtube.com/watch?v=OBxj0tI_txs&feature=player_embedded
        • lwowiak51 misterpee -moskalowy piesek 10.04.11, 12:41
          napisal "bierzaco". Ty nie jestes nawet pierwszym pokoleniem ,ktore pisze po polsku.
          Moze Twoje wnuki beda mialy szanse.Zyj nadzieja.
          • misterpee Re: Fantazje perwertow staja sie rzeczywistoscia 11.04.11, 01:44
            americansjourney.blogspot.com/2011/04/6-year-old-girl-groped-by-tsa.html
            A propos Lwowiaka - darmowy entuzjastyczny spell-check w polskim jezyku dla wrogow.
Inne wątki na temat:
Pełna wersja