Gość: guardian
IP: 168.103.126.*
03.04.03, 16:43
Wednesday April 2, 2003
The Guardian
Hatra, one of Iraq's ancient sites threatened by the current war
This week, B52s were circling the holy city of Najaf, emptying, we are told,
their payloads on to the Medina division of the Republican guard. They know
all about slaughter in this city of half a million people now surrounded by
the tanks of the US Seventh Cavalry, Custer's old devil-may-care outfit.
Ali, the charismatic son-in-law of the Prophet - who occupies a place in the
Shi'ite pantheon of similar significance to Christ - was murdered at the
gates of Najaf. His tomb has been one of the most sacred Shi'ite shrines
since.
Up the road at Kerbala (pronounced Herbala, despite what the BBC says), Ali's
son Hussein, his family and followers were massacred by the Sunnis in 680AD
in a "turkey-shoot" of a battle that divides Islam to this day. Hussein's
mausoleum is like the Vatican, Gethsemane and the Wailing Wall rolled into
one. It is at Kerbala where Saddam, like his namesake, seems to have decided
to stand and fight.
In museums and universities across the world, scholars and curators are
fearful of another armageddon. One not perpetrated on the Iraqi people but on
their history and monuments. Iraq, particularly the green heart of
Mesopotamia, the fertile crescent of land between the rivers Tigris and
Euphrates, is the cradle of civilisation, the land of Nineveh, Babylon,
Nimrud and Uruk, the world's first city. This is where the Sumerians invented
writing 5,000 years ago, where the epic of Gilgamesh - the model for Noah and
the flood - was committed to cuneiform a millennium and a half before Homer.
It is the land of the Old Testament, the Tower of Babel and of Ur, where
Abraham, the father of the three great monotheistic religions, was born.
It may have only a single official Unesco listing but, with 1,000
acknowledged archaeological sites, Iraq is one huge world heritage zone. And
on to this in the past few days have poured 740 Tomahawk cruise missiles,
8,000 smart bombs and an unknown number of stupid ones. One of the first acts
of the war was an attack on the museum in Saddam's home town of Tikrit. To an
Iraqi regime eager for ammunition for propaganda, this was proof of American
and British barbarism. The allies preferred to see it as a symbolic strike at
the personality cult of Saddam.
The museum in Mosul, the northern city that is home to the oldest churches in
the world, is also dedicated to a pernicious personality cult, that of
Sennacherib, a seventh-century BC Assyrian ruler. That, too, has been hit.
The Mosul museum houses some of the most important finds from nearby Nineveh
and Nimrud, like the giant winged Assyrian bulls with human heads that awe
visitors to the British Museum and thousands of cuneiform clay tablets that
have yet to be deciphered. The museum's director, a Christian, like many in
Mosul, has spent the last year blast-proofing the windows and evacuating her
most delicate exhibits. Some, however, were simply too big to move.
But it is the damage that may be happening out of sight of the cameras that
has historians and archaeologists worried. At Trinity College, Cambridge,
Professor Nicholas Postgate is resigned to the worst but angry about the
destruction.
On Iraq's pancake-flat southern plain, archeological sites are the only
raised features, the only cover and, therefore, key military positions. "Some
are 30 metres high and extend over kilometres," Postgate says. "With modern
machinery, an entire 6,000-year-old village can be recycled into a defensive
earthwork in a day or two, and even old-fashioned trenches, which were much
used in the last hostilities, can do irreparable damage."
American bulldozers razed the ruins of Tell al-Lahm, south of Ur, during the
last Gulf war. What might a squadron of B52s be able to do? From the air,
archaeological trenches are easily mistaken for military emplacements, and
therefore fair game for a pummelling. But it's not just the direct hits that
wreck. In 1991, the great arch of Ctesphion, still the widest unsupported
brick arch in the world, was cracked by the rumble of American carpet
bombing.
The Iraqis themselves, of course, are adept at recycling ancient defences.
There is evidence that tanks were parked around ancient sites during the last
war, and the Americans are quick to point to the Iraqi airbase that sits in
the shadow of the great ziggurat of Ur. With an administration stuffed full
of biblical literalists - Christian and Zionist fundamentalists - it is easy
to understand their anger at the Iraqis' use of the city of Abraham as a
shield. But what few in the Pentagon seem to realise is that the Ur airbase
was built by the British in the days of its colonial mandate, when the RAF
first demonstrated the civilising capabilities of bombing civilians from the
air.
John Curtis, the keeper of the department of the ancient near east at the
British Museum, visited Ur last spring and has little doubt the Americans
strafed the ziggurat - a great, stepped pyramid - with heavy machine-gun fire
the last time they passed that way. "Whether this was an accident, I couldn't
say," he says. A fair amount of what he drily calls "bayonet archaeology" had
also gone on, presumably by passing GIs.
Postgate is not so phlegmatic. "This argument that it doesn't matter if these
places are hit because the Iraqis are using the archaeology like human
shields is a non-starter. If you put a machine-gun emplacement anywhere in
Mosul, for instance, it will be next to antiquities. That is the nature of
the country, but that doesn't make Mosul a valid target."
And there is another reason, he argues, why the Iraqis are justified in
putting machine guns outside museums. In the aftermath of the last Gulf war,
when large parts of the country rose up against Saddam, several important
museums and archaeological sites were looted in the chaos. Around 4,000
precious objects went missing and more were destroyed. Most of the stolen
items followed the well-worn route to Israel, Switzerland and, finally, to
London, where many Assyrian pieces, broken up for easier transit, ended up on
the art market or in the back rooms of antiquarian dealers. Having failed, as
a pariah state, to get them back through official channels, the Iraqis were
still trying to buy some back from western collectors when hostilities
started. "I am not trying to make any argument for Saddam, but any
responsible government must protect their cultural heritage," Postgate says.
But, for all his butchery, torture and repression, Saddam has been mostly a
good thing for archaeology. He has his reasons, of course. Like many a
dictator before him, he promised national rebirth and a repeat of the glories
of the past, comparing himself to Nebuchadnezzar who built the Hanging
Gardens of Babylon. He even rebuilt the old city walls with bricks embossed
with his own name next to that of Nebuchadnezzar. You don't have to be an
expert to see this exercise as a crime against archaeology and aesthetics.
Then there is the presidential palace Saddam built himself on the site.
But Saddam saw protecting Iraq's heritage as a patriotic duty, even if his
methods were brutal. Five years ago, 10 men from near Mosul who cut the head
off an Assyrian winged bull at Khorsabad were executed. Such was the
desperation of Iraqis that the looting and smuggling continued.
Since the phones went down 12 days ago, nothing has been heard from the
museum in Baghdad. Emails have gone unanswered, too. The culture ministry is
said to have been bombed. The museum sits close to a telephone exchange and a
television transmitter in the Salihyia district. Trenches have been dug
outside.
At the British Museum, Curtis is worried on three fronts.