Gość: wierzbowa IP: *.porcupine.dialup.pol.co.uk 23.06.03, 18:02 Did anyone read it? And what do you think about it? Was it worth waiting two years for? Odpowiedz Link Zgłoś Obserwuj wątek Podgląd Opublikuj
Gość: chickenShorts Re: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix IP: *.w80-13.abo.wanadoo.fr 23.06.03, 20:08 Gość portalu: wierzbowa napisał(a): > Did anyone read it? And what do you think about it? Was it worth waiting two > years for? Not really, according to 11 year old Emma: (...)"The characters are a bit stereotyped and the way JK Rowling writes is flat and boring. It is like a grown-up talking to children. I find it quite patronising. I am surprised that adults read the books. They are children's fantasy stories. Maybe they want to read them to reconnect with their childhoods, maybe they want to see what the fuss is all about, or maybe they are bored."(...) www.guardian.co.uk/uk_news/story/0,3604,982153,00.html Odpowiedz Link Zgłoś
Gość: awalk Re: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix IP: *.warszawa.sdi.tpnet.pl 23.06.03, 20:52 Gość portalu: chickenShorts napisał(a): > Not really, according to 11 year old Emma: href="http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk_news/story/0,3604,982153,00.html"target="_blank">www.guardian.co.uk/uk_news/story/0,3604,982153,00.html</a> Not so bad according to this one books.guardian.co.uk/harrypotter/story/0,10761,982214,00.html Odpowiedz Link Zgłoś
Gość: wierzbowa Re: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix IP: *.wolf.dialup.pol.co.uk 24.06.03, 13:38 I must say, I’m a bit confused. Emma sounds extremely mature for me, that’s one thing. The other is; she doesn’t like fantasy stories, but prefers “realistic stories”, so it’s rather obvious she won’t like Potter books, isn’t it. I finished new Harry Potter book yesterday and I just would like to know what the other people – who actually have read previous Potter books, think about it. I, personally still don’t know did I like it or not. There are few things which just … hmm … don’t fit nicely, but maybe it’s just me. Odpowiedz Link Zgłoś
Gość: chickenShorts Re: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix IP: *.w80-13.abo.wanadoo.fr 24.06.03, 15:51 Gość portalu: wierzbowa napisał(a): > I must say, I’m a bit confused. Emma sounds extremely mature for me, that > ’s > one thing. The other is; she doesn’t like fantasy stories, but > prefers “realistic stories”, so it’s rather obvious she won > 8217;t like Potter > books, isn’t it. > I finished new Harry Potter book yesterday and I just would like to know what > the other people – who actually have read previous Potter books, think ab > out > it. I, personally still don’t know did I like it or not. There are few th > ings > which just … hmm … don’t fit nicely, but maybe it’s jus > t me. Well, I read "Harry Patter à l'école des sorciers" which is the French translation of the first of Potter books. We live in France & I did it simply in order to encourage my 10 year old son to read it... He became quite a fun of the saga but rather thanks to a film than my 'sacrifice'. I seem to remember musing at the time of my reading on my childhood books, Szklarski's 'Tomek...' series or Jules Verne... or Winnetou... Harry Potter is rubbish, come on... Odpowiedz Link Zgłoś
Gość: inglisz girl Re: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix IP: *.neoplus.adsl.tpnet.pl 23.06.03, 21:51 powalona book. Odpowiedz Link Zgłoś
Gość: awalk Re: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix IP: *.warszawa.sdi.tpnet.pl 26.06.03, 15:52 another review www.nytimes.com/2003/06/26/nyregion/26HARR.html Odpowiedz Link Zgłoś